Decision details
Remedial works in connection with high risk RAAC at the Recreation Centre.
Decision Maker: Director of Finance and Assets and Deputy Section 151 Officer - Gemma Bell
Decision status: Recommendations Approved
Is Key decision?: No
Is subject to call in?: No
Decision:
To instruct King Builders Ltd to carry out
remedial works (structural strengthening) in connection with high
risk RAAC panels found following structural engineers survey at the
Recreation Centre.
Reasons for the decision:
The Teaching Pool, Splashpad and School Change
areas are currently closed on the advice of structural engineers
following a survey carried out at the Recreation Centre to identify
the presence of RAAC
within the structure. The survey highlighted that some of the RAAC
panels identified were in too poor a condition to allow the
Recreation Centre to operate as normal due to the unknown
structural stability of the panels within the roof structure.
Following consultation with The Cheltenham Trust a 6 week closure
was agreed in order to allow remedial work to commence within the
critical (high risk) areas highlighted above. In order to prevent a
prolonged closure the normal procurement route could not be adhered
to. Therefore, Property informally spoke with a number of local
Building Contractors inviting them to tender from structural
engineers drawings and specification, requesting commitment that
they could deliver within the timescale.
King Builders were the only Contractor who showed an interest in
undertaking the specialised works and advised they has previous
expertise in this area. The Property Team have worked with King
Builders for a number of years on a wide variety of projects and
found them to be diligent, competent Contractors.
The Structural Engineers were satisfied that provided we could make
a start within weeks of receiving their survey report, could
demonstrate we had appointed a contractor and agreed a rolling
programme of
remedial works, we would not need to close the Change Village or
corridor areas adjacent and works could take place safely whilst
some of the facility is still in operation. Had we not been able to
appoint a
Contractor within weeks of receiving the structural engineers
report their advice was to close the Change Village. The impact of
this would have been such that we would have had to close the Main
Swimming Pool through lack of changing facilities and
showers.
Alternative options considered:
To carry out a full open tender exercise, this
would require closure of the entire wetside area of the facility
for at least 6 months which would have had a detrimental impact on
the income stream of the Operator. Therefore this option was
discounted in favour of a rolling programme with an experienced
Contractor having previously demonstrated an excellent reputation
for delivery.
Declarations: n/a
Other reasons / organisations consulted
Consultation and permission sought from Gemma
Bell, Director of Finance & Assets
Contact: Gemma Bell, Director of Finance and Assets and Deputy S151 Officer Email: [email protected].
Publication date: 14/03/2024
Date of decision: 01/03/2024